Kafka Producers: Synchronous vs. Asynchronous Production

In Apache Kafka, producers are responsible for sending records to topics. A crucial decision when building a Kafka producer is how to handle the acknowledgment of sent messages. This choice significantly impacts performance, reliability, and the overall behavior of your data pipeline. We will explore the two primary modes: synchronous and asynchronous production.

Synchronous Production

Synchronous production means that the producer sends a message and then waits for an acknowledgment from the Kafka broker before sending the next message. This approach provides strong guarantees about message delivery but can lead to lower throughput due to the blocking nature of the operation.

Synchronous production waits for confirmation before sending the next message.

When a producer sends a message synchronously, it blocks its execution thread until it receives an acknowledgment from the Kafka broker. This ensures that the message has been successfully received and replicated according to the topic's configuration (e.g., acks setting).

In a synchronous model, the producer's send() method is a blocking call. The thread that calls send() will pause its execution until the broker responds. This response indicates whether the message was successfully written to the leader partition and, depending on the acks configuration, replicated to follower partitions. While this guarantees that the producer knows the message status, it limits the rate at which messages can be sent, as each send operation must complete before the next can begin.

Asynchronous Production

Asynchronous production allows the producer to send messages without waiting for an immediate acknowledgment. Instead, it uses callbacks or futures to handle the results of the send operation, enabling higher throughput and better resource utilization.

Asynchronous production sends messages without blocking, using callbacks for results.

With asynchronous production, the producer sends a message and immediately continues with its work. The result of the send operation (success or failure) is handled later via a callback function or by inspecting a Future object. This non-blocking approach significantly boosts throughput.

In the asynchronous model, the send() method returns immediately, often returning a RecordMetadata future. The producer can then continue to send more messages. The acknowledgment status is managed asynchronously. This is typically achieved by providing a callback function to the send() method. This callback is invoked by the Kafka client when the acknowledgment is received from the broker. This allows the producer to efficiently send a large volume of messages without being bottlenecked by individual send confirmations.

Key Differences and Considerations

Feature	Synchronous Production	Asynchronous Production
Blocking	Yes, the send call blocks.	No, the send call returns immediately.
Throughput	Lower	Higher
Latency	Higher per message due to waiting.	Lower per message, but overall latency for delivery can vary.
Complexity	Simpler to implement and reason about.	Requires handling callbacks or futures for results.
Error Handling	Errors are immediately visible.	Errors are handled via callbacks, requiring careful implementation.
Use Case	When immediate confirmation is critical and throughput is less of a concern.	When high throughput is required, and eventual consistency is acceptable.

The acks configuration in Kafka producers is crucial for both synchronous and asynchronous modes. acks=0 means no acknowledgment, acks=1 means acknowledgment from the leader, and acks=all (or -1) means acknowledgment from the leader and all in-sync replicas. This setting directly influences the durability guarantees.

What is the primary trade-off between synchronous and asynchronous Kafka production?

Synchronous production offers stronger delivery guarantees and simpler error handling but at the cost of lower throughput. Asynchronous production achieves higher throughput by not blocking but requires more complex handling of delivery results.

Choosing the Right Approach

The choice between synchronous and asynchronous production depends on your application's specific requirements. If your application needs to ensure that every message is successfully written before proceeding, synchronous might be suitable, though often a well-implemented asynchronous producer with appropriate error handling and retry mechanisms can achieve similar reliability with better performance. For high-volume data ingestion, asynchronous production is almost always the preferred method.

Imagine sending letters. Synchronous is like waiting at the post office for a receipt for each letter before writing the next. Asynchronous is like dropping all your letters in the mailbox and then checking your email later for delivery confirmations. The latter lets you write and send many more letters in the same amount of time.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Learning Resources

Kafka Producer Configuration - Apache Kafka Documentation(documentation)

Official documentation detailing all producer configurations, including those related to acknowledgments and batching, which are key to understanding sync vs. async behavior.

Kafka Producer API - JavaDocs(documentation)

Detailed Java API documentation for KafkaProducer, showing the `send()` methods and how to attach callbacks for asynchronous operations.

Understanding Kafka Producer Performance(blog)

A comprehensive blog post from Confluent that dives deep into producer performance tuning, explaining the impact of batching, compression, and acknowledgment settings.

Kafka: The Definitive Guide - Producer Design(paper)

An excerpt from a popular book that explains the fundamental design of Kafka producers, including how they send messages and handle acknowledgments.

Kafka Producer Callbacks Explained(tutorial)

A straightforward tutorial explaining how to implement and use callbacks in Kafka producers for handling asynchronous send results.

Kafka Producer Best Practices(blog)

Another valuable blog post from Confluent focusing on best practices for building robust and efficient Kafka producers, covering error handling and idempotence.

Apache Kafka: Producer and Consumer(tutorial)

A general overview of Kafka producers and consumers, touching upon the send mechanisms and the role of acknowledgments.

Kafka Producer `send()` Method and Futures(tutorial)

A practical Java-focused tutorial demonstrating how to use the Kafka Producer API, including examples of asynchronous sends using Futures.

Kafka Producer `acks` Configuration(documentation)

Direct link to the Javadoc for the `acks` configuration parameter, explaining its values and impact on durability and performance.

Kafka Producer Retries and Idempotence(blog)

Explains the concepts of producer retries and idempotence, which are critical for ensuring reliable message delivery in asynchronous scenarios.

Asynchronous vs. Synchronous Production