Terraform Provisioners: Best Practices for Infrastructure Management

Terraform provisioners are powerful tools that allow you to execute scripts or commands on remote or local machines during resource creation, update, or destruction. While they offer flexibility, their misuse can lead to complex, brittle, and hard-to-debug infrastructure. This module explores best practices to leverage provisioners effectively and avoid common pitfalls.

Understanding Provisioner Types

Terraform offers two primary provisioner types:

code

remote-exec

and

code

local-exec

. Understanding their differences is crucial for choosing the right tool for the job.

Provisioner	Execution Location	Use Cases	Considerations
`remote-exec`	On the resource being created (e.g., a VM)	Bootstrapping software, configuring services, running application deployments	Requires network connectivity to the resource; can be complex to manage credentials and state.
`local-exec`	On the machine running Terraform	Interacting with local tools, triggering CI/CD pipelines, generating configuration files	Less dependent on remote resource availability; can be useful for tasks not directly tied to the provisioned resource.

When to Use Provisioners (and When Not To)

Provisioners are best used for tasks that are difficult or impossible to achieve declaratively within Terraform's resource model. This often includes initial bootstrapping or complex configuration steps.

Think of provisioners as a last resort for tasks that cannot be handled by declarative resource configurations or by using configuration management tools like Ansible, Chef, or Puppet.

Avoid using provisioners for tasks that can be managed declaratively. For example, installing packages or configuring services should ideally be handled by the machine's operating system or a dedicated configuration management tool. Over-reliance on provisioners can make your Terraform code harder to read, maintain, and debug.

Key Best Practices for Provisioners

To ensure your provisioner usage is robust and maintainable, adhere to these core principles:

1. Prefer Configuration Management Tools

Integrate with dedicated configuration management tools (Ansible, Chef, Puppet, SaltStack) whenever possible. These tools are designed for complex configuration tasks and offer better state management, idempotency, and error handling than raw scripts.

2. Keep Scripts Idempotent

Ensure your scripts can be run multiple times without unintended side effects. This is crucial because Terraform might re-run provisioners under certain conditions, and idempotency prevents breaking changes.

What does it mean for a script to be idempotent?

An idempotent script produces the same result regardless of how many times it is executed.

3. Use `when` and `on_failure` Appropriately

The

code

when

argument controls when a provisioner runs (e.g.,

code

create

code

update

code

destroy

). The

code

on_failure

argument dictates behavior if the provisioner fails (e.g.,

code

continue

code

fail

). Use

code

on_failure = "fail"

for critical setup steps to halt the Terraform apply if the provisioner fails.

4. Avoid Provisioners on `destroy` if Possible

Provisioners on destroy can be tricky. If a resource is already unhealthy or unreachable, a destroy provisioner might fail, potentially leaving resources in an inconsistent state. Consider using separate cleanup scripts or relying on the cloud provider's lifecycle hooks.

5. Manage Sensitive Data Securely

Never embed sensitive information (passwords, API keys) directly in provisioner scripts. Use environment variables, secrets management tools, or Terraform's sensitive variables feature.

6. Limit Provisioner Scope

Keep provisioner scripts focused on a single, well-defined task. Complex scripts are harder to debug and maintain. Break down large tasks into smaller, manageable scripts.

7. Use `local-exec` for Local Operations

For tasks that don't require execution on the remote resource,

code

local-exec

is often a safer and more reliable choice. This includes generating configuration files or interacting with local tools.

Example Scenario: Bootstrapping a Web Server

Consider bootstrapping a web server on an EC2 instance. Instead of a complex

code

remote-exec

script, it's better to use a configuration management tool or user data.

A common pattern is to use remote-exec to install an agent for a configuration management tool (like Ansible) or to download and run a more comprehensive bootstrap script. This separates the initial provisioning from the detailed configuration. For example, a remote-exec provisioner might download an Ansible playbook and then execute it. The playbook itself would handle tasks like installing Nginx, configuring virtual hosts, and deploying application code, ensuring idempotency and better manageability.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Alternatively, cloud-init (user data) on AWS or cloud-config on other platforms can be used to perform initial setup tasks like installing packages and starting services upon instance launch, often a more robust approach than

code

remote-exec

for basic bootstrapping.

Provisioner Lifecycle and Dependencies

Terraform executes provisioners after a resource has been created but before it's considered fully created. Provisioners are also subject to resource dependencies. If a provisioner depends on another resource, Terraform will ensure that dependent resource is created first.

Loading diagram...

Understanding this lifecycle helps in debugging and ensuring that the environment is ready for the provisioner's execution.

Conclusion

Terraform provisioners are a powerful but potentially complex feature. By adhering to best practices, such as preferring configuration management tools, ensuring idempotency, and limiting their scope, you can effectively use provisioners to bootstrap and configure your infrastructure without introducing unnecessary fragility.

Learning Resources

Terraform Provisioners Documentation(documentation)

The official HashiCorp documentation on Terraform provisioners, covering syntax, types, and lifecycle.

Terraform Provisioner Best Practices(blog)

A blog post from HashiCorp discussing the purpose and best practices for using provisioners.

Terraform Provisioners: When and How to Use Them(blog)

An article detailing the use cases and potential pitfalls of Terraform provisioners.

Integrating Terraform with Ansible(documentation)

Guidance on how to effectively integrate Terraform with Ansible for robust infrastructure provisioning.

Terraform `local-exec` Provisioner Explained(blog)

A deep dive into the `local-exec` provisioner, its use cases, and best practices.

Terraform `remote-exec` Provisioner Explained(blog)

An explanation of the `remote-exec` provisioner, its capabilities, and how to use it safely.

Idempotency in Configuration Management(blog)

Explains the concept of idempotency, which is critical for understanding provisioner best practices.

Terraform Best Practices: Provisioners(tutorial)

A tutorial offering practical advice and examples for using Terraform provisioners effectively.

Using Cloud-Init for EC2 Instance Initialization(documentation)

AWS documentation on user data (cloud-init), a common alternative to `remote-exec` for initial bootstrapping.

Terraform Provisioners: A Deep Dive(video)

A video tutorial that explores Terraform provisioners in detail, including practical examples and common mistakes.