Choosing the Right Minimum Viable Product (MVP) Type
A Minimum Viable Product (MVP) is a version of a new product which allows a team to collect the maximum amount of validated learning about customers with the least effort. But not all MVPs are created equal. Understanding the different types of MVPs can help you select the most appropriate approach for your specific business goals and stage of development.
Why MVP Type Matters
The choice of MVP type directly impacts the speed of learning, the cost of development, and the type of feedback you can gather. A well-chosen MVP type aligns with your core hypotheses and accelerates your path to product-market fit.
Common MVP Types and Their Applications
Concierge MVPs offer highly personalized customer experiences to validate demand.
In a Concierge MVP, you manually perform the core service or function for your early customers. This allows for deep customer interaction and validation of the core value proposition without building a scalable product.
The Concierge MVP is ideal when the core value of your product lies in a service that can be delivered manually. Think of early-stage concierge services, personalized coaching, or bespoke travel planning. While resource-intensive, it provides invaluable qualitative feedback and a clear understanding of customer needs and pain points. The key is to learn if customers are willing to pay for the service, even if delivered manually.
Wizard of Oz MVPs simulate a functional product through manual backend operations.
Similar to the Concierge MVP, the Wizard of Oz MVP presents a seemingly automated user interface to the customer, but all the 'magic' happens manually behind the scenes. This tests the user experience and demand for a feature-rich product.
This MVP type is excellent for testing complex functionalities or user interfaces that would be expensive to build upfront. For example, an AI-powered recommendation engine could be simulated by a human manually selecting recommendations. The goal is to validate the desirability of the user experience and the core functionality before investing in automation. It's crucial to be transparent with early users about the manual nature of the service if possible, or to have a clear plan for automation.
Landing Page MVPs gauge interest and collect leads before product development.
A Landing Page MVP is a single web page designed to explain the product's value proposition and encourage sign-ups or pre-orders. It's a low-fidelity way to test market demand and gather potential customer contact information.
This is one of the simplest and fastest MVPs to create. It's perfect for testing the market's appetite for a new product or feature. By driving traffic to the landing page through marketing efforts, you can measure conversion rates (e.g., email sign-ups, pre-orders) to validate demand. If the conversion rates are low, you know to pivot or refine your offering before significant development investment.
Piecemeal MVPs assemble existing tools to create a functional solution.
The Piecemeal MVP leverages existing tools and platforms to create a functional product. Instead of building from scratch, you integrate off-the-shelf components to deliver the core value proposition.
This approach is cost-effective and quick. For instance, you might use a combination of email, spreadsheets, and existing software to deliver a service. The goal is to validate the core customer problem and solution by providing a working product, even if it's not a fully integrated or branded solution. It helps you learn about user workflows and feature priorities.
Single-Feature MVPs focus on validating one core functionality.
A Single-Feature MVP, often called a 'Minimum Lovable Product' (MLP) or 'Minimum Marketable Feature' (MMF), delivers a single, well-executed core feature that provides significant value to a specific user segment.
This type of MVP is about doing one thing exceptionally well. It's useful when you have a strong hypothesis about a single feature that will be the primary driver of customer adoption. By focusing on a single feature, you can deliver a polished experience and gather focused feedback on that specific aspect of your product, reducing complexity and development time.
Comparing MVP types involves understanding their core mechanism and primary learning objective. A Concierge MVP manually delivers a service to learn about customer needs. A Wizard of Oz MVP simulates automation to test user experience. A Landing Page MVP tests market demand via sign-ups. A Piecemeal MVP uses existing tools to deliver a functional product. A Single-Feature MVP focuses on perfecting one core function.
Text-based content
Library pages focus on text content
| MVP Type | Primary Mechanism | Key Learning | Effort Level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concierge | Manual service delivery | Customer needs & willingness to pay | High |
| Wizard of Oz | Simulated automation | User experience & demand for features | Medium to High |
| Landing Page | Web page with call to action | Market demand & interest | Low |
| Piecemeal | Integration of existing tools | Core problem/solution validation | Low to Medium |
| Single-Feature | One core, well-executed feature | Value of a specific feature | Medium |
Selecting the Right MVP for Your Startup
When choosing an MVP type, consider these factors:
- Your Core Hypothesis: What is the riskiest assumption you need to test?
- Customer Interaction: How much direct interaction do you need with customers?
- Development Resources: What is your budget and timeline?
- Market Signal: What kind of signal are you trying to elicit (e.g., sign-ups, actual usage, pre-orders)?
The goal of any MVP is learning. Choose the type that allows you to learn the most about your riskiest assumptions with the least amount of effort.
Iterating Beyond the MVP
Once you've gathered validated learning from your initial MVP, you'll use that feedback to iterate. This might involve refining the existing MVP, pivoting to a new direction, or building out more features based on customer demand. The MVP is not the end goal, but a crucial step in the product development lifecycle.
Learning Resources
An official explanation of the MVP concept from the originator of the Lean Startup methodology.
A comprehensive guide to understanding what an MVP is, why it's important, and how to build one effectively.
Explores various MVP types with examples, helping you decide which approach best suits your project.
A thought-provoking article discussing the evolution and nuances of the MVP concept in modern product development.
A clear and concise video explaining the concept of an MVP and its importance in the startup journey.
A practical guide on the steps involved in building an MVP, from ideation to launch.
Provides a broad overview of the MVP concept, its origins, and its application in various industries.
An introductory video to the core principles of the Lean Startup, which heavily influences MVP strategy.
Details the Concierge MVP approach, its benefits, and when it's most effective for validating business ideas.
A comprehensive resource covering MVP definition, types, benefits, and a step-by-step guide to building one.