Understanding Claims in Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC)
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) of India provides a framework for resolving insolvency and bankruptcy cases. A crucial aspect of this process is the classification and treatment of claims filed by various creditors against a corporate debtor. Understanding these classifications is fundamental to grasping how the IBC operates and how assets are distributed.
What is a Claim?
Under the IBC, a 'claim' means a right to relief in respect of a debt, or liability or a duty. This definition is broad and encompasses various types of financial and non-financial obligations that a corporate debtor may owe to its stakeholders.
Classification of Claims
Claims are primarily categorized to determine their priority and the rights of the claimants during the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP). The main classifications are: Financial Claims, Operational Claims, Secured Claims, and Unsecured Claims.
Financial Claims
A financial claim is a claim in respect of a financial debt or liability. A 'financial debt' means a debt along with interest, if any, actually paid or due. This typically includes loans, debentures, and other forms of financial accommodation provided to the corporate debtor. Financial creditors have significant voting rights in the Committee of Creditors (CoC).
It is a claim in respect of a financial debt or liability, often involving money lent or due.
Operational Claims
An operational claim arises from the provision of goods or services to the corporate debtor. This includes claims for wages, salaries, dues to suppliers, service providers, and other operational creditors. These claims are generally subordinate to financial claims.
Think of operational claims as the 'bills to pay' for the day-to-day running of the business.
Secured Claims
A secured claim is one where the creditor holds security interest over the assets of the corporate debtor. This security can be created by way of pledge, mortgage, hypothecation, or charge. Secured creditors have the right to realize their security and recover their dues. They can also choose to give up their security and be treated as an unsecured creditor.
Unsecured Claims
An unsecured claim is a claim that is not secured by any specific asset of the corporate debtor. This category typically includes operational creditors and financial creditors who have not provided any security. In the event of liquidation, unsecured creditors are paid after secured creditors (who have realized their security) and workmen's dues.
| Claim Type | Nature of Claim | Typical Creditors | Priority (General) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial Claim | Debt arising from financial accommodation | Banks, Financial Institutions, Debenture Holders | High (often forms the CoC) |
| Operational Claim | Debt for goods/services provided | Suppliers, Service Providers, Employees | Lower (paid after secured and workmen's dues) |
| Secured Claim | Debt backed by collateral/security interest | Banks, Financial Institutions, specific lenders | High (priority over collateral) |
| Unsecured Claim | Debt without specific collateral | Operational Creditors, Financial Creditors without security | Lower (paid after secured and workmen's dues) |
Interplay and Hierarchy
It's important to note that a creditor can sometimes fall into multiple categories. For instance, a bank that has lent money (financial creditor) might also have a charge over specific assets (secured creditor). In such cases, the secured aspect usually takes precedence in terms of recovery from the collateral. The IBC establishes a clear waterfall mechanism for distribution of proceeds, prioritizing certain classes of creditors over others to ensure fairness and order in the resolution process.
The classification of claims under the IBC is central to the distribution of assets. Financial creditors, who provide funds, typically form the Committee of Creditors (CoC) and have significant decision-making power. Operational creditors, who provide goods and services, have a lower priority. Secured creditors can enforce their security interest, while unsecured creditors are paid from the residual assets. This hierarchy ensures that those who have provided essential services or goods are compensated, but also that those who have financed the company's operations are prioritized in a structured manner.
Text-based content
Library pages focus on text content
Key Roles in Claim Management
Several key roles are involved in managing these claims:
- Resolution Professional (RP): The RP is responsible for receiving and collating all claims, verifying them, and forming the Committee of Creditors (CoC).
- Committee of Creditors (CoC): Composed primarily of financial creditors, the CoC reviews resolution plans and makes decisions regarding the corporate debtor's future.
- Adjudicating Authority (NCLT): The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) oversees the entire process and passes orders on various aspects, including admission of claims and approval of resolution plans.
Conclusion
A thorough understanding of claim classification is vital for anyone involved in insolvency and bankruptcy proceedings under the IBC. It dictates voting rights, recovery prospects, and the overall trajectory of the resolution process.
Learning Resources
The official bare act of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, providing the complete legal text and amendments.
An official overview of the IBBI's role, functions, and the framework of the IBC, including explanations of key processes.
A detailed blog post explaining the core concepts of the IBC, including claim resolution and creditor rights.
An in-depth article dissecting the various types of claims, their treatment, and the process of submission and verification under the IBC.
A white paper providing a comprehensive overview of the IBC, its objectives, and key provisions, including claim management.
A video tutorial explaining the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP), focusing on the submission and handling of claims and the role of the Committee of Creditors.
A video explaining the different categories of creditors under the IBC and how their claims are treated and prioritized.
A Wikipedia article providing a general overview of the IBC, its history, objectives, and key features, including claim resolution.
An article detailing the legal landscape of insolvency and bankruptcy in India, with a focus on the IBC and its operational aspects.
Official rules and regulations governing the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), which plays a critical role in claim adjudication and resolution.