Understanding Cost Estimation and Cardinality in PostgreSQL

In PostgreSQL, efficient data retrieval relies heavily on the query planner's ability to estimate the 'cost' of different execution plans and predict the 'cardinality' (number of rows) at various stages of query processing. This module delves into these fundamental concepts, crucial for optimizing your SQL queries.

What is Cardinality?

Cardinality refers to the number of rows that a particular operation or condition is expected to return. For example, if you query a table of users and filter by

code

country = 'USA'

, the cardinality of that filter is the number of users from the USA. Accurate cardinality estimates are vital for the query planner to choose the most efficient execution path.

Cardinality is the estimated number of rows returned by a query operation.

The query planner uses statistics to predict how many rows will match a WHERE clause or a join condition. This prediction is called cardinality.

PostgreSQL maintains statistics about the data distribution in your tables, including the number of distinct values in columns and their frequencies. When a query is executed, the planner uses these statistics to estimate the cardinality of intermediate results. For instance, if a column has many distinct values, a filter on that column might result in a low cardinality. Conversely, if a column has few distinct values, a filter might yield a high cardinality. Inaccurate cardinality estimates can lead the planner to choose suboptimal execution plans, such as using a sequential scan when an index scan would be faster, or vice-versa.

What is Cost Estimation?

Cost estimation is the process by which the PostgreSQL query planner assigns a numerical 'cost' to each potential execution plan for a given SQL query. This cost is an abstract measure representing the estimated resources (CPU, I/O, memory) required to execute that plan.

Cost estimation assigns a numerical value to the predicted resource usage of a query plan.

The planner evaluates multiple ways to execute a query and assigns a cost to each. The plan with the lowest estimated cost is typically chosen.

The query planner considers various access methods (e.g., sequential scan, index scan) and join methods (e.g., nested loop, hash join, merge join). For each combination, it estimates the cost based on factors like the estimated cardinality of intermediate results, the cost of reading data blocks (I/O), and the cost of processing rows (CPU). The planner's goal is to find the plan with the minimum estimated cost. However, the accuracy of this estimation is directly tied to the accuracy of the cardinality estimates. If cardinality is overestimated, a plan that seems expensive might be chosen incorrectly.

Imagine a query planner as a navigator planning a road trip. Cardinality is like estimating the number of cars you'll encounter on different road segments (e.g., a busy highway vs. a quiet country lane). Cost estimation is like assigning a 'difficulty' or 'time' score to each route based on factors like distance, estimated traffic (cardinality), and road type (access method). The navigator chooses the route with the lowest estimated difficulty/time.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

How Cardinality and Cost Estimation Work Together

Cardinality estimates directly influence cost estimates. A higher estimated cardinality for a join condition might lead the planner to favor a hash join over a nested loop join, as hash joins generally perform better with larger intermediate result sets. Conversely, a low cardinality might make a nested loop join more attractive if the inner table can be efficiently accessed via an index.

Accurate statistics are the bedrock of effective query optimization. Without them, the planner is essentially guessing, leading to inefficient query execution.

Factors Affecting Cardinality and Cost

Several factors can impact the accuracy of these estimates:

Statistics: Outdated or insufficient statistics are the most common culprits. Running
code
```
ANALYZE
```
or
code
```
VACUUM ANALYZE
```
regularly is crucial.
Data Skew: If data is unevenly distributed (e.g., one value appears far more often than others), standard statistics might not capture this skew accurately.
Complex Predicates: Highly complex WHERE clauses or functions within predicates can be harder for the planner to estimate accurately.
Index Selectivity: The effectiveness of an index depends on its selectivity, which is related to the cardinality of the values it indexes.

What is the primary reason for inaccurate query plans in PostgreSQL?

Outdated or insufficient statistics about the data distribution.

Improving Estimates

To improve cardinality and cost estimates, consider the following:

Regularly
code
ANALYZE
tables: This command updates the statistics used by the planner.
Increase statistics target: For columns with skewed data or complex distributions, you can increase the statistics target using
code
```
ALTER TABLE ... ALTER COLUMN ... SET STATISTICS ;
```
.
Use Extended Statistics: For correlations between columns, PostgreSQL supports extended statistics.
Understand your data: Knowledge of data distribution and potential skew is invaluable.

Which PostgreSQL command updates table statistics?

ANALYZE

Learning Resources

PostgreSQL Documentation: Query Planner Cost Constants(documentation)

Official PostgreSQL documentation explaining the statistics and cost parameters that influence the query planner's decisions.

PostgreSQL Documentation: Statistics(documentation)

Detailed explanation of how PostgreSQL collects and uses statistics to estimate query costs and cardinalities.

Understanding PostgreSQL's Query Planner(blog)

A blog post that breaks down the query planner, including how it uses statistics and estimates costs.

PostgreSQL EXPLAIN: The Ultimate Guide(blog)

A comprehensive guide to using the EXPLAIN command to analyze query execution plans and understand cost estimates.

PostgreSQL Cardinality Estimation(documentation)

Specific section within the PostgreSQL docs detailing the mechanisms behind cardinality estimation.

PostgreSQL Extended Statistics(documentation)

Documentation on creating and using extended statistics to improve estimates for correlated columns.

How to Tune PostgreSQL for Performance(blog)

A practical guide to performance tuning in PostgreSQL, with emphasis on statistics and query planning.

PostgreSQL Query Optimization: A Deep Dive(blog)

An in-depth look at query optimization strategies in PostgreSQL, covering cost-based optimization and statistics.

PostgreSQL: The Cost of Poor Statistics(blog)

Explains the negative impact of stale or insufficient statistics on query performance and how to address it.

PostgreSQL EXPLAIN ANALYZE Explained(blog)

A tutorial on using EXPLAIN ANALYZE to see actual execution times and row counts, comparing them to planner estimates.