Declarative vs. Imperative Infrastructure as Code

Understanding the difference between declarative and imperative approaches is fundamental to mastering Infrastructure as Code (IaC) with tools like Terraform. This distinction impacts how you define, manage, and update your infrastructure.

Imperative Approach

In an imperative approach, you specify a sequence of commands or steps to achieve a desired state. You tell the system how to do something. Think of it like providing a recipe with detailed instructions: 'First, create a server. Then, install this software. Next, configure this firewall rule.'

Imperative IaC: Telling the system how to achieve a state through a series of commands.

This method focuses on the process. You write scripts that execute specific actions in a defined order to build or modify infrastructure. If a step fails, the entire process might halt.

Imperative IaC often involves scripting languages like Bash, Python, or PowerShell. While flexible, it can become complex to manage as infrastructure grows. Tracking the current state and ensuring idempotency (running the same command multiple times has the same effect as running it once) can be challenging. If you need to change a resource, you might have to manually undo previous steps or write new scripts to handle the modification.

Declarative Approach

The declarative approach, which Terraform champions, focuses on the desired end state. You describe what you want your infrastructure to look like, and the IaC tool figures out the necessary steps to get there. It's like telling a chef the final dish you want, and they handle the cooking process.

Declarative IaC: Describing the desired end state, letting the tool determine the steps.

You define the target configuration (e.g., 'I want a web server with these specifications, running on this network'). The IaC tool then calculates the most efficient way to create or update the infrastructure to match that description.

Declarative IaC tools are designed to be idempotent. If you run the same configuration multiple times, the tool will only make changes if the current state doesn't match the desired state. This makes infrastructure management more predictable and less error-prone. Terraform uses HashiCorp Configuration Language (HCL) to define infrastructure resources, making it readable and maintainable.

Imagine building a LEGO castle. An imperative approach would be like having a manual that says: 'Step 1: Take a red brick. Step 2: Place it here. Step 3: Take a blue brick. Step 4: Place it next to the red one.' You follow each instruction precisely. A declarative approach would be like having a picture of the finished castle and saying, 'Build me a castle that looks like this.' The builder (the IaC tool) figures out the best way to assemble the bricks to match the picture, regardless of the exact order they pick them up.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Feature	Imperative IaC	Declarative IaC
Focus	How to achieve the state (process)	What the state should be (end result)
Method	Sequence of commands/scripts	Desired configuration state
Idempotency	Challenging to ensure	Built-in and core principle
Complexity Management	Can become complex with scale	Easier to manage and scale
Example Tools	Shell scripts, Chef (procedural mode)	Terraform, Ansible (declarative mode), CloudFormation

Terraform's declarative nature is a key reason for its popularity. It simplifies complex infrastructure management by abstracting away the procedural details.

Why Declarative is Preferred for IaC

The declarative model offers significant advantages for managing infrastructure:

Predictability: The system always aims for the defined state, reducing unexpected outcomes.
Maintainability: Configurations are easier to read, understand, and modify.
Scalability: It handles changes and growth more gracefully.
Reusability: Configurations can be easily shared and reused across projects.
State Management: IaC tools track the current state, enabling intelligent updates and drift detection.

In which IaC approach do you specify the exact steps to achieve a desired infrastructure state?

The imperative approach.

What is the primary benefit of Terraform's declarative approach?

It simplifies infrastructure management by focusing on the desired end state, making it more predictable and maintainable.

Learning Resources

Terraform Documentation: Infrastructure as Code(documentation)

HashiCorp's official introduction to IaC concepts, explaining the benefits and principles behind managing infrastructure through code.

Terraform Basics: Declarative vs. Imperative(video)

A clear video explanation contrasting imperative and declarative approaches in the context of Terraform.

Understanding Declarative vs. Imperative Programming(blog)

A blog post that breaks down the core differences between declarative and imperative programming paradigms, applicable to IaC.

What is Infrastructure as Code?(documentation)

Red Hat provides a comprehensive overview of IaC, its benefits, and how it contrasts with traditional infrastructure management.

Ansible vs. Terraform: Declarative vs. Procedural(blog)

This tutorial compares Ansible and Terraform, highlighting their declarative and procedural (imperative) aspects.

The Principles of Infrastructure as Code(blog)

A deep dive into the core principles that make IaC effective, including the importance of declarative configuration.

Declarative vs Imperative Programming(wikipedia)

Wikipedia's entry on declarative programming, providing a foundational understanding of the concept.

Terraform: Declarative Infrastructure Automation(video)

A video explaining how Terraform's declarative approach enables efficient and reliable infrastructure automation.

Infrastructure as Code: A Beginner's Guide(documentation)

TechTarget offers a beginner-friendly guide to IaC, explaining its purpose and benefits.

Understanding IaC: Declarative vs. Imperative(blog)

This article explains the fundamental differences between declarative and imperative programming styles with examples.

Declarative vs. Imperative IaC