Designing Experiments to Study Social Behavior
Behavioral economics and experimental design offer powerful tools to understand how people make decisions, especially in social contexts. This module focuses on the principles and practices of designing experiments to empirically test theories about social behavior.
Key Principles of Experimental Design
Effective experimental design is crucial for isolating the effects of specific variables on social behavior. This involves careful planning to ensure validity and reliability.
Randomization is key to creating comparable groups.
Random assignment ensures that, on average, participants in different experimental conditions are similar before the intervention begins. This minimizes the chance that pre-existing differences, rather than the experimental manipulation, explain the observed outcomes.
Randomization, specifically random assignment to treatment and control groups, is a cornerstone of experimental design. It aims to distribute all potential confounding variables (both observed and unobserved) equally across groups. This statistical balancing allows researchers to attribute any significant differences in outcomes directly to the independent variable being tested, thereby establishing causality.
To create comparable groups and minimize confounding variables.
Types of Experimental Designs
Different experimental designs are suited for different research questions. Understanding these designs helps in selecting the most appropriate method.
| Design Type | Description | Key Advantage | Potential Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Between-Subjects | Participants are assigned to only one experimental condition. | Avoids carryover effects from one condition to another. | Requires larger sample sizes to achieve statistical power. |
| Within-Subjects (Repeated Measures) | The same participants experience all experimental conditions. | Increases statistical power and reduces variability. | Risk of order effects (e.g., practice, fatigue). |
| Mixed Designs | Combines between-subjects and within-subjects factors. | Allows examination of both between-group differences and within-group changes. | Can be complex to analyze and interpret. |
Common Social Behavior Experiments
Many classic and contemporary experiments in behavioral economics and psychology explore fundamental aspects of social behavior, such as cooperation, fairness, and altruism.
The Ultimatum Game reveals insights into fairness and reciprocity.
In the Ultimatum Game, one player proposes how to split a sum of money, and the other player can accept or reject the offer. Rejection means neither player gets anything. Low offers are often rejected, demonstrating a concern for fairness beyond pure self-interest.
The Ultimatum Game is a simple yet powerful experimental paradigm. Player A (the proposer) receives a sum of money and proposes a split to Player B (the responder). Player B can either accept the offer, in which case the money is split as proposed, or reject the offer, in which case neither player receives any money. Empirical findings consistently show that responders reject offers perceived as unfair (e.g., significantly less than 50%), even though accepting any positive offer would be financially rational. This behavior highlights the role of social preferences, such as a desire for fairness and a willingness to punish unfairness, in economic decision-making.
The Prisoner's Dilemma is a foundational game in game theory and experimental economics used to study cooperation and defection. Two players independently choose to either 'Cooperate' or 'Defect'. If both cooperate, they both receive a moderate reward. If one defects and the other cooperates, the defector receives a high reward, and the cooperator receives a low punishment. If both defect, they both receive a low punishment. The dilemma arises because, from a purely rational self-interested perspective, defecting is always the dominant strategy, regardless of the other player's choice. However, if both players follow this logic, they both end up worse off than if they had both cooperated. This game is often used to explore factors influencing cooperation, such as repeated interactions, communication, and social norms.
Text-based content
Library pages focus on text content
Designing Your Own Experiment
When designing an experiment, consider the following steps to ensure a robust and informative study.
Loading diagram...
Pilot testing your experiment is crucial to identify any unforeseen issues with instructions, procedures, or stimuli before the main data collection.
Ethical Considerations
Ethical conduct is paramount in any research involving human participants. Researchers must prioritize the well-being and rights of those involved.
Informed consent, ensuring participants understand the study and agree to participate voluntarily.
Key ethical principles include obtaining informed consent, ensuring anonymity and confidentiality, minimizing harm, and debriefing participants after the study.
Learning Resources
This article provides a clear overview of the fundamental principles of experimental design, including independent and dependent variables, control groups, and randomization.
While a book, this introduction offers foundational concepts in behavioral economics, often referencing experimental methods used to study decision-making.
A concise video explaining the rules and common outcomes of the Ultimatum Game, a classic experiment in behavioral economics.
Scribbr offers a comprehensive guide to experimental design, covering different types of designs and how to implement them effectively.
A detailed exploration of the Prisoner's Dilemma, its game theory implications, and its use in experimental research on cooperation.
This seminal handbook provides in-depth discussions on experimental methods and findings across various economic fields, including social behavior.
This video offers a beginner-friendly introduction to game theory, which is essential for understanding many social behavior experiments.
The American Psychological Association's ethical code outlines the principles and standards researchers must adhere to when working with human participants.
This paper discusses the growing importance and methodology of field experiments in economics, often applied to social behavior.
The National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) highlights research and experiments in behavioral economics, often linking to working papers and findings.