Designing Subgraph Schemas for Federated GraphQL

Federated GraphQL allows you to build a unified GraphQL API from multiple independent GraphQL services, known as subgraphs. Designing effective subgraph schemas is crucial for a well-performing and maintainable federated API. This involves careful consideration of data ownership, relationships, and query efficiency.

Core Principles of Subgraph Schema Design

When designing subgraph schemas, several key principles guide the process to ensure a robust and scalable federated API. These principles help maintain consistency, manage complexity, and optimize performance across distributed services.

Each subgraph should own a distinct set of entities and fields.

A subgraph is responsible for a specific domain or set of data. This clear ownership prevents conflicts and simplifies development and maintenance.

The principle of data ownership dictates that each subgraph should be the definitive source for a particular set of entities and their fields. This means that if a field is defined in a subgraph, that subgraph is responsible for resolving it. This approach promotes modularity and reduces the likelihood of conflicting data definitions across different services.

What is the primary responsibility of a subgraph in a federated GraphQL API?

To own and resolve a specific set of entities and their fields.

Defining Entities and Relationships

Entities are the core objects in your GraphQL schema. How you define them and their relationships between subgraphs is fundamental to federation.

Use entity extensions to link related data across subgraphs.

When an entity is defined in one subgraph but needs to be extended with fields from another, use the @extends directive. This allows subgraphs to contribute to a shared entity without duplicating its core definition.

Federation relies on shared entity definitions. If an entity, like a User, is primarily defined in a UserService subgraph, another subgraph, like an OrderService, might need to add fields to it (e.g., User.orders). This is achieved by defining the User entity in the OrderService subgraph using the @extends directive and then adding the new fields. The gateway uses the @key directive on the base entity definition to understand how to link these extended types.

Consider a Product entity. The ProductService subgraph might define its core fields like id, name, and price. A ReviewService subgraph could then extend the Product entity to add a reviews field, which would be a list of Review objects. The ProductService would define the @key directive on Product (e.g., @key(fields: "id")), allowing the gateway to resolve the Product by its id and then delegate the reviews field to the ReviewService.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Querying Across Subgraphs

The gateway orchestrates queries across subgraphs. Understanding how to structure queries for efficient data fetching is vital.

Leverage entity resolution for efficient cross-subgraph data fetching.

When a query needs data from multiple subgraphs, the gateway first resolves the primary entity using its @key directive. Then, it makes subsequent requests to other subgraphs for fields that are part of those extended entities.

The federation gateway plays a crucial role in query planning. When a client requests data that spans multiple subgraphs, the gateway identifies the primary entity and its defining subgraph. It fetches the necessary fields for that entity. If the query also requests fields that belong to an extended version of that entity in another subgraph, the gateway will then make a separate request to that specific subgraph, passing the necessary entity identifiers (e.g., id) to resolve the requested fields. This process is known as entity resolution.

Think of entity resolution like a smart librarian. You ask for a book (entity), the librarian knows which shelf (subgraph) it's on and retrieves it. If you also need related articles (extended fields), the librarian knows which other sections (subgraphs) to check and fetches those too, all based on the book's identifier.

Best Practices for Subgraph Schema Design

Adhering to best practices ensures your federated GraphQL API is robust, scalable, and easy to manage.

Aspect	Good Practice	Potential Pitfall
Entity Ownership	Each entity has a single primary owner.	Multiple subgraphs defining the same core entity fields.
Relationships	Use `@key` and `@extends` for cross-subgraph relationships.	Embedding large objects directly instead of linking via IDs.
Naming Conventions	Consistent naming across all subgraphs.	Inconsistent or ambiguous field names.
Query Performance	Design subgraphs to resolve their own data efficiently.	Over-reliance on the gateway to perform complex joins.
Schema Evolution	Introduce new fields and types gradually.	Breaking changes to existing fields or types.

What directive is used to link an entity defined in one subgraph to another subgraph that extends it?

The @extends directive.

Example: User and Order Subgraphs

Let's illustrate with a common scenario: a

code

User

entity and its relationship with

code

Order

entities.

Loading diagram...

In this simplified example, the

code

User

subgraph owns the

code

User

entity. The

code

Order

subgraph defines its own

code

Order

entity and uses

code

@key(fields: "userId")

to indicate that it can resolve orders based on a

code

userId

. The gateway orchestrates this, fetching user details from the

code

User

subgraph and then using the

code

userId

to fetch related orders from the

code

Order

subgraph.

Learning Resources

Apollo Federation: Schema Design(documentation)

Official Apollo Federation documentation covering the core principles and best practices for designing subgraph schemas.

Apollo Federation: Entities(documentation)

Detailed explanation of how entities are defined, extended, and resolved across subgraphs in Apollo Federation.

GraphQL Federation: A Practical Guide(blog)

A practical blog post that walks through the concepts of GraphQL federation and schema design with examples.

Building a Federated GraphQL API with Apollo Federation(video)

A video tutorial demonstrating how to build a federated GraphQL API, including schema design considerations.

Designing GraphQL Schemas: A Practical Guide(video)

A comprehensive video on general GraphQL schema design principles, which are foundational for federation.

GraphQL Federation: A Deep Dive(video)

An in-depth video exploring the architecture and design patterns of federated GraphQL APIs.

Federated GraphQL: The Future of APIs?(blog)

An article discussing the benefits and architectural advantages of using federated GraphQL.

GraphQL Schema Design Best Practices(tutorial)

A tutorial focused on best practices for designing robust and scalable GraphQL schemas.

Understanding GraphQL Federation(tutorial)

An introductory tutorial to GraphQL Federation, explaining its core concepts and benefits.

GraphQL(wikipedia)

Wikipedia entry providing a general overview of GraphQL, its history, and its core concepts.