Formulating Research Questions and Hypotheses in AI Research

In the dynamic field of Artificial Intelligence, particularly in Deep Learning and Large Language Models (LLMs), the ability to formulate precise and impactful research questions and hypotheses is paramount. This skill guides your entire research process, from experimental design to the interpretation of results. A well-crafted question or hypothesis acts as a compass, ensuring your efforts are focused and contribute meaningfully to the advancement of AI.

Understanding Research Questions

A research question is a clear, concise, and focused question that your research aims to answer. It identifies the problem or phenomenon you are investigating. In AI research, these questions often explore the capabilities, limitations, ethical implications, or novel applications of AI models.

What makes a good AI research question?

A good AI research question is specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART), and it addresses a gap in current knowledge or a practical problem.

When formulating a research question in AI, consider the following:

Specificity: Avoid broad questions. Instead of 'How can LLMs be improved?', ask 'How does fine-tuning an LLM on domain-specific medical literature affect its accuracy in diagnosing rare diseases?'
Measurability: Can you define metrics to evaluate the answer? For example, 'What is the impact of prompt engineering techniques on the factual accuracy of LLM-generated summaries?' can be measured by comparing generated summaries against ground truth.
Achievability: Is the question answerable within your resources (time, data, computational power)?
Relevance: Does the question address a significant problem or a gap in current AI understanding?
Novelty: Does it offer a new perspective or approach?

Formulating Hypotheses

A hypothesis is a testable statement that proposes a potential answer to your research question. It's an educated guess about the relationship between variables. In AI, hypotheses often predict the outcome of an experiment or the effect of a specific intervention on a model's performance.

Types of Hypotheses in AI Research

Hypotheses can be directional (predicting a specific outcome) or non-directional (predicting a relationship without specifying direction), and often involve comparing different model architectures, training methods, or data augmentation techniques.

There are two primary types of hypotheses:

Null Hypothesis (H₀): This states there is no significant difference or relationship between variables. For example, 'There is no significant difference in the perplexity scores of an LLM trained with standard backpropagation versus an LLM trained with a novel optimization algorithm.'
Alternative Hypothesis (H₁ or Hₐ): This states there is a significant difference or relationship. It can be:
- Directional: 'An LLM trained with a novel optimization algorithm will achieve significantly lower perplexity scores than an LLM trained with standard backpropagation.'
- Non-directional: 'There will be a significant difference in perplexity scores between LLMs trained with standard backpropagation and those trained with a novel optimization algorithm.'

What is the primary purpose of a research question in AI research?

To clearly define the problem or phenomenon that the research aims to investigate and answer.

What is the difference between a null hypothesis and an alternative hypothesis?

The null hypothesis states no significant effect or relationship, while the alternative hypothesis states there is a significant effect or relationship.

Connecting Questions and Hypotheses

Your research question and hypothesis should be intrinsically linked. The hypothesis provides a specific, testable prediction that, if supported by evidence, answers your research question. For instance, if your research question is 'Does data augmentation improve the robustness of image classification models against adversarial attacks?', your hypothesis might be 'Data augmentation techniques will significantly increase the accuracy of image classification models when subjected to adversarial perturbations.'

The process of formulating research questions and hypotheses can be visualized as a funnel. You start with a broad area of interest, narrow it down to a specific research question, and then propose a testable answer in the form of a hypothesis. This hypothesis then guides the design of experiments to collect data, which is analyzed to either support or refute the hypothesis, ultimately providing an answer to the research question.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Examples in Deep Learning and LLMs

Let's consider some practical examples:

Research Question: How does the choice of activation function (e.g., ReLU, GELU, Swish) impact the convergence speed and final performance of a Transformer-based LLM on a sentiment analysis task?
- Hypothesis (Directional): Using the Swish activation function will lead to faster convergence and higher accuracy on the sentiment analysis task compared to ReLU and GELU.
Research Question: What is the effect of different regularization techniques (e.g., dropout, weight decay, early stopping) on mitigating catastrophic forgetting in continual learning scenarios for image recognition?
- Hypothesis (Directional): Implementing a combination of elastic weight consolidation (EWC) and dropout will significantly reduce catastrophic forgetting compared to using dropout alone or weight decay alone.

Remember, the goal is not always to 'prove' your hypothesis, but to rigorously test it and learn from the results, whether they confirm or contradict your initial prediction.

Iterative Refinement

Formulating research questions and hypotheses is often an iterative process. As you delve deeper into the literature, conduct preliminary experiments, or encounter unexpected results, you may need to refine your questions and hypotheses. This iterative nature is a strength, allowing your research to adapt and evolve based on new insights.

Learning Resources

How to Write a Great Research Question(documentation)

Provides a comprehensive guide on crafting effective research questions, including criteria for good questions and examples.

Formulating a Hypothesis(documentation)

Explains the concept of a hypothesis, its role in research, and how to formulate one correctly, including null and alternative hypotheses.

Research Questions and Hypotheses(documentation)

A university library guide detailing the relationship between research questions and hypotheses, offering practical advice for academic research.

The Art of Asking Questions(video)

A TED Talk by Warren Berger emphasizing the importance of asking questions and how to ask better ones, applicable to any field including AI.

Deep Learning Research: From Idea to Publication(blog)

A blog post discussing the research process in deep learning, touching upon idea generation and problem formulation.

How to Write a Good Research Hypothesis(video)

A YouTube tutorial explaining the steps and considerations for formulating a strong research hypothesis with clear examples.

Large Language Models: A Survey(paper)

A foundational survey paper on LLMs that can inspire research questions by highlighting current trends, challenges, and future directions.

Hypothesis Testing(tutorial)

A series of lessons on hypothesis testing, covering the fundamental statistical concepts needed to validate AI research hypotheses.

What is a Research Question?(blog)

An article that breaks down the components of a good research question and provides examples across different disciplines.

Formulating Research Questions(documentation)

A practical, step-by-step guide on how to develop effective research questions for various academic projects.