Prospect Theory: Understanding Decisions Under Uncertainty
Prospect Theory, developed by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, offers a descriptive model of how people make decisions when faced with risk and uncertainty. It challenges the traditional economic assumption of rational choice by highlighting systematic psychological biases that influence our judgments and choices.
Key Concepts of Prospect Theory
Value is perceived relative to a reference point, not in absolute terms.
We evaluate outcomes based on gains and losses from a specific reference point, rather than on the final state of wealth.
Prospect Theory posits that individuals assess potential outcomes in terms of gains and losses relative to a reference point. This reference point is often the current status quo, but it can also be an aspiration or expectation. This framing significantly impacts decision-making, as the same objective outcome can be perceived differently depending on whether it's framed as a gain or a loss.
Diminishing sensitivity applies to both gains and losses.
The impact of a gain or loss decreases as its magnitude increases.
The value function in Prospect Theory is characterized by diminishing sensitivity. This means that the psychological impact of an additional dollar is greater when you have less money than when you have more. For example, the difference between 20 feels more significant than the difference between 1010. This applies to losses as well.
Loss aversion: Losses loom larger than equivalent gains.
People feel the pain of a loss more intensely than the pleasure of an equivalent gain.
A core tenet of Prospect Theory is loss aversion. The psychological impact of losing a certain amount of money is typically greater than the psychological impact of gaining the same amount. This asymmetry explains why people are often more motivated to avoid losses than to seek gains, even when the objective probabilities are the same.
Probability weighting: People overweight small probabilities and underweight large probabilities.
Our perception of probability is distorted, leading to predictable biases.
Prospect Theory also incorporates a probability weighting function. This function suggests that people do not perceive probabilities linearly. Small probabilities are often overweighted (e.g., lottery tickets), while moderate to high probabilities are often underweighted. This distortion contributes to phenomena like the certainty effect, where people prefer a sure outcome over a probabilistic one, even if the expected value is lower.
The value function in Prospect Theory is typically depicted as an S-shaped curve. It is concave in the domain of gains (reflecting diminishing sensitivity to gains) and convex in the domain of losses (reflecting diminishing sensitivity to losses). The curve is steeper in the loss domain than in the gain domain, illustrating loss aversion. The reference point is the origin (0,0) on this graph.
Text-based content
Library pages focus on text content
Applications of Prospect Theory
Prospect Theory has profound implications across various fields, from finance and marketing to public policy and health.
Finance and Investment
In finance, Prospect Theory helps explain phenomena like the equity premium puzzle (why stocks historically offer higher returns than bonds) and the disposition effect (investors tend to sell winning stocks too early and hold losing stocks too long). Loss aversion drives investors to avoid realizing losses, even if it means holding onto underperforming assets.
Marketing and Consumer Behavior
Marketers leverage Prospect Theory by framing prices and offers to appeal to consumers' perceptions of gains and losses. For instance, 'limited-time discounts' or 'buy one, get one free' promotions tap into the fear of missing out (FOMO) and the desire for a perceived gain. Free trials also utilize the endowment effect, a related concept where people value something more once they own it.
Public Policy and Health
Public policymakers use insights from Prospect Theory to design more effective interventions. For example, framing health messages in terms of avoiding losses (e.g., 'smoking causes disease') can be more persuasive than framing them in terms of gaining benefits (e.g., 'quitting smoking improves health'). Similarly, opt-out systems for organ donation or retirement savings plans are more effective due to loss aversion and inertia.
Understanding prospect theory is crucial for anyone looking to understand why people make seemingly irrational decisions, especially when money or risk is involved.
Losses loom larger than equivalent gains; people feel the pain of a loss more intensely than the pleasure of an equivalent gain.
It is concave, reflecting diminishing sensitivity to gains.
Learning Resources
The seminal paper by Kahneman and Tversky that introduced Prospect Theory, providing the foundational concepts and mathematical framework.
While a book, this link leads to a Goodreads page summarizing the key ideas, including extensive coverage of Prospect Theory and its implications for decision-making.
An accessible explanation of Prospect Theory, its core components, and its relevance in financial decision-making.
An overview of Daniel Kahneman's work, including Prospect Theory, within the context of behavioral economics.
A video explanation that breaks down the core concepts of Prospect Theory, including the value function and probability weighting.
A lecture from a Coursera course that delves into Prospect Theory and the critical concept of loss aversion with practical examples.
While Tversky passed away before receiving the Nobel Prize, this link provides access to his posthumously published lecture, which discusses his foundational work including Prospect Theory.
Explores how marketers utilize the principles of Prospect Theory, such as framing and loss aversion, to influence consumer behavior.
This book by Thaler and Sunstein extensively applies behavioral economics, including Prospect Theory, to public policy and decision architecture.
Explains the framing effect, a key component of Prospect Theory, with examples of how the presentation of information influences choices.