Robustness Checks and Sensitivity Analysis in Behavioral Economics
In behavioral economics, understanding the reliability and generalizability of findings is paramount. Robustness checks and sensitivity analysis are critical tools that researchers use to ensure their results are not driven by specific methodological choices or data peculiarities. They help build confidence in the observed behavioral patterns and the underlying economic theories.
What are Robustness Checks?
Robustness checks are procedures designed to verify that the main conclusions of a study hold even when certain assumptions or specifications are altered. They answer the question: 'Are my results stable?' This involves re-running the analysis with different, but theoretically plausible, variations of the original model or data.
Robustness checks confirm that your findings are not accidental.
By changing aspects of your analysis, you test if the core result remains consistent. This increases confidence in your conclusions.
Common variations include using different functional forms (e.g., linear vs. log-linear), alternative measures for key variables, different sets of control variables, or excluding specific subsets of the data (e.g., outliers, specific demographic groups). If the main findings persist across these variations, the results are considered robust.
What is Sensitivity Analysis?
Sensitivity analysis is closely related to robustness checks but often focuses more on understanding how changes in specific input parameters or assumptions affect the output of a model. It quantifies the impact of uncertainty in these inputs on the model's predictions or conclusions.
Sensitivity analysis quantifies how much your results change when inputs change.
It helps identify which assumptions are most critical to your findings.
For instance, in a behavioral experiment, you might test how sensitive your estimated treatment effect is to the assumed discount rate or the probability of future rewards. This analysis can highlight which parameters are crucial drivers of the observed behavior and where further investigation might be needed.
Why are they Important in Behavioral Research?
Behavioral economics often deals with complex human decision-making, which can be influenced by a multitude of factors. The context of an experiment, the specific framing of questions, and individual differences can all play a role. Robustness checks and sensitivity analysis are vital for:
- Generalizability: Ensuring findings from a specific experimental setting or sample can be applied more broadly.
- Causality: Strengthening causal claims by showing that the observed effect is not due to omitted variables or specific model choices.
- Transparency and Reproducibility: Providing a clear account of how the results were tested, making the research more transparent and easier for others to reproduce.
- Identifying Key Drivers: Pinpointing which behavioral parameters or contextual factors are most influential on the outcomes.
Think of robustness checks as stress-testing your findings. If your results hold up under various pressures, they are more likely to be reliable.
Common Types of Robustness Checks
| Type of Check | Description | Example in Behavioral Research |
|---|---|---|
| Alternative Model Specification | Using different functional forms or including/excluding control variables. | Testing if the effect of a financial incentive on effort remains significant when adding controls for education level or prior experience. |
| Alternative Variable Measurement | Using different proxies or operationalizations for key variables. | Checking if the observed impact of social norms on charitable giving is consistent whether 'social norms' are measured by peer behavior or self-reported attitudes. |
| Subsample Analysis | Re-running the analysis on different subsets of the data. | Examining if the gender pay gap estimate differs significantly between urban and rural participants, or between younger and older cohorts. |
| Alternative Estimation Methods | Employing different statistical techniques to estimate the model. | Comparing results from OLS regression with those from a probit model if the outcome variable is binary. |
| Excluding Outliers | Removing data points that are extreme or unusual. | Assessing if a particularly high or low response from a participant unduly influences the average treatment effect. |
Performing Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity analysis often involves systematically varying key parameters within a model to observe the impact on the outcome. This can be done through:
Identify critical assumptions by testing their impact.
This helps understand the boundaries of your findings.
For example, if you are modeling intertemporal choice, you might vary the discount rate to see how sensitive the predicted consumption patterns are to different levels of patience. This can reveal whether your conclusions about saving behavior are heavily dependent on a specific assumed discount factor.
Imagine a behavioral experiment measuring the effect of framing on purchasing decisions. The core finding might be that framing a product as '90% fat-free' leads to higher sales than '10% fat'. A sensitivity analysis could explore how this effect changes if the price is also varied, or if the product description is slightly altered. This visualizes how changes in input parameters (price, description) influence the output (sales difference due to framing).
Text-based content
Library pages focus on text content
Best Practices
When conducting robustness checks and sensitivity analysis, it's important to be systematic and transparent. Clearly state which checks were performed and why. Avoid 'p-hacking' by only reporting checks that yield favorable results. The goal is to demonstrate the reliability of your findings, not to find a specification that supports a pre-determined outcome.
Transparency in reporting your robustness checks is as important as performing them.
Learning Resources
Provides a clear overview of why and how to conduct robustness checks in economic research, with practical examples.
A practical guide to performing sensitivity analysis, explaining its importance in validating research findings across disciplines.
A discussion on the role of robustness checks in ensuring the credibility and reliability of empirical findings in social sciences.
A video tutorial explaining the fundamental concepts of sensitivity analysis and its applications.
An educational video explaining the concept of robustness in econometric analysis and its significance.
A comprehensive overview of sensitivity analysis, its definitions, methods, and applications in various fields.
Discusses best practices for reproducible research, which inherently includes robust methodology and transparent reporting of checks.
A foundational textbook that covers various econometric techniques, including discussions on model specification and diagnostic checks.
An accessible introduction to behavioral economics, providing context for the types of studies where robustness checks are crucial.
Explores how sensitivity analysis is used to evaluate the robustness of policy recommendations to underlying assumptions.