LibrarySocial Preferences: Fairness, Reciprocity, Altruism

Social Preferences: Fairness, Reciprocity, Altruism

Learn about Social Preferences: Fairness, Reciprocity, Altruism as part of Behavioral Economics and Experimental Design

Social Preferences: Fairness, Reciprocity, and Altruism in Behavioral Economics

Traditional economic models often assume individuals are purely self-interested, seeking to maximize their own utility. However, behavioral economics recognizes that human decisions are influenced by a complex interplay of psychological, social, and emotional factors. Among these, social preferences—our concern for the well-being and actions of others—play a crucial role in shaping economic behavior. This module explores three key social preferences: fairness, reciprocity, and altruism.

Fairness

Fairness refers to an individual's desire for equitable outcomes and processes. People often care not just about their own payoff, but also about how that payoff compares to others, and whether the distribution of resources or treatment is perceived as just. This can lead individuals to reject unfair offers, even if accepting them would result in a positive payoff for themselves.

Fairness drives decisions even when self-interest suggests otherwise.

In experiments like the Ultimatum Game, participants often reject offers they deem unfair, demonstrating a preference for equity over pure monetary gain.

The concept of fairness is often studied using experimental games. In the Ultimatum Game, one player (the proposer) suggests how to divide a sum of money with another player (the responder). The responder can either accept the offer, in which case the money is split as proposed, or reject it, in which case neither player receives anything. While a purely self-interested responder would accept any offer greater than zero, empirical evidence shows that responders frequently reject offers perceived as unfair (e.g., less than 20-30% of the total sum). This behavior suggests a strong aversion to inequity and a willingness to punish unfairness, even at a personal cost.

Reciprocity

Reciprocity is the tendency to respond to a positive action with another positive action, and to a negative action with another negative action. This can manifest as 'strong reciprocity' (willingness to reward kindness and punish unkindness, even at a cost) or 'weak reciprocity' (responding in kind to actions, but without incurring a cost).

What is the core principle of reciprocity in behavioral economics?

Responding to others' actions in kind, whether positive or negative.

Experiments like the Trust Game illustrate reciprocity. In this game, an investor is given a sum of money and can choose to send any portion of it to a trustee. The amount sent is multiplied, and the trustee then decides how much to return to the investor. A positive return from the trustee demonstrates reciprocity, rewarding the investor's trust. Conversely, a low or zero return can be seen as a failure of reciprocity.

Altruism

Altruism involves acting out of concern for the well-being of others, even at a cost to oneself. This is distinct from reciprocity, as it doesn't necessarily require a prior positive action from the recipient. Pure altruism means deriving utility from another person's increased well-being, regardless of one's own outcome or any exchange.

Consider a scenario where someone donates to a charity. If their motivation is solely to improve the lives of others, even if it means sacrificing personal comfort or resources, this is a manifestation of altruism. This can be visualized as a selfless act where the giver's utility increases directly with the recipient's welfare, independent of any direct return or social norm enforcement.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Evidence for altruism can be found in charitable giving, volunteering, and situations where individuals incur costs to help strangers. Behavioral economists often use dictator games to study altruism, where one person (the dictator) decides how to split a sum of money with another person (the recipient), who has no say in the matter. While some dictators keep all the money, many give a portion, suggesting a concern for the recipient's welfare.

Interplay and Experimental Design

These social preferences—fairness, reciprocity, and altruism—are not mutually exclusive and often interact. Experimental design in behavioral economics is crucial for isolating and measuring these preferences. By carefully constructing games and controlling for confounding factors, researchers can gain insights into the underlying motivations driving economic decisions.

PreferenceCore MotivationExperimental Illustration
FairnessDesire for equitable outcomes and processesUltimatum Game (rejecting unfair offers)
ReciprocityResponding to actions in kind (kindness with kindness, unkindness with punishment)Trust Game (returning multiplied funds)
AltruismConcern for the well-being of others, independent of personal gain or exchangeDictator Game (giving a portion of money to a stranger)

Understanding social preferences is key to building more realistic economic models and designing effective policies that account for human behavior beyond pure self-interest.

Learning Resources

The Foundations of Behavioral Economics(wikipedia)

Learn about the pioneers of behavioral economics and their contributions to understanding how psychological factors influence economic decisions.

Nobel Prize in Economics 2002: Kahneman and Smith(wikipedia)

Explore the work of Daniel Kahneman and Vernon Smith, who laid the groundwork for experimental economics and the study of social preferences.

Behavioral Economics: An Introduction(video)

A foundational video introducing the core concepts of behavioral economics and its departure from traditional assumptions.

The Ultimatum Game Explained(video)

A clear explanation and demonstration of the Ultimatum Game, highlighting how fairness influences decisions.

The Dictator Game: A Behavioral Economics Experiment(video)

Understand the setup and implications of the Dictator Game for studying altruism and fairness.

Reciprocity in Economics(blog)

An accessible overview of reciprocity as a concept in economic behavior and its empirical evidence.

Fairness as a Social Preference(paper)

A seminal academic paper that delves into the empirical evidence for fairness as a social preference in economic decision-making.

Altruism and Fairness: Experimental Evidence(paper)

This paper presents experimental findings on altruism and fairness, distinguishing between these two important social preferences.

Behavioral Economics: Foundations and Applications(documentation)

A comprehensive resource that covers the theoretical underpinnings and practical applications of behavioral economics.

The Handbook of Experimental Economics(documentation)

A detailed reference for understanding the methodologies and findings in experimental economics, including studies on social preferences.