Sub-topic 2: Character Development: Parties and Witnesses

In legal brief writing and persuasive advocacy, understanding and presenting the 'character' of parties and witnesses is crucial. This isn't about their moral standing, but rather how their background, motivations, and demeanor can influence a judge or jury's perception of their testimony and claims. Effective character development humanizes the case and makes it more relatable and persuasive.

Understanding the 'Character' in a Legal Context

The 'character' of a party or witness in a legal setting refers to the traits, background, and circumstances that are relevant to their credibility, reliability, and the overall narrative of the case. This includes:

Background and Experience: Relevant professional, educational, or life experiences that lend weight to their testimony or claims.
Motivations and Interests: What drives their actions or statements? Understanding their stakes can explain their behavior.
Demeanor and Presentation: How they appear and behave during testimony or in their interactions can influence perception.
Consistency and Credibility: How their story aligns with other evidence and their own past statements.

Developing the Narrative of Parties

When presenting parties in a legal brief, the goal is to frame their role and perspective in a way that supports your case. This involves highlighting their legitimate interests, their adherence to legal or ethical standards, and their overall reasonableness. For example, in a contract dispute, presenting one party as a diligent business owner seeking fair compensation, while the other is portrayed as evasive or unreasonable, can significantly sway opinion.

Think of parties and witnesses as characters in a story. Your brief is the script, and you are the director, guiding the audience's perception of each role.

Strategic Presentation of Witness Character

The way a witness is introduced and their testimony is framed can profoundly impact how it's received. This involves:

Establishing Expertise: For expert witnesses, highlighting their credentials, experience, and publications builds immediate authority.
Demonstrating Reliability: For fact witnesses, emphasizing their direct observation, clear memory, and lack of bias can bolster their testimony.
Humanizing the Witness: Sharing relevant, non-prejudicial personal details can make them more relatable and their testimony more impactful.
Anticipating Attacks: Proactively addressing potential impeachment strategies (e.g., prior inconsistent statements, bias) can neutralize them before they are raised by the opposition.

What is the primary goal when presenting a witness's 'character' in a legal brief?

To establish their credibility and reliability, making their testimony more persuasive to the judge or jury.

Visualizing the 'Character Arc' of a Witness. Imagine a witness's testimony as a narrative. The 'character arc' involves their introduction (establishing their role and credibility), the development of their testimony (presenting facts and observations), and the resolution (reinforcing their reliability and impact on the case). This arc is influenced by their background, motivations, and how their story aligns with other evidence. A strong arc leads to a more convincing narrative.

📚

Text-based content

Library pages focus on text content

Ethical Considerations

While persuasive presentation is key, it must always be grounded in truth and ethical conduct. Lawyers have a duty to present evidence truthfully and cannot knowingly present false testimony or misrepresent a party's character. The goal is to highlight relevant strengths and frame the narrative persuasively, not to deceive.

Learning Resources

The Art of Persuasion: Crafting Compelling Legal Arguments(blog)

This article from the American Bar Association explores general principles of persuasion in legal advocacy, touching on how to frame arguments effectively.

Federal Rules of Evidence: Rule 608 - A Witness's Character for Truthfulness or Untruthfulness(documentation)

This is the foundational legal rule governing the admissibility of evidence about a witness's character for truthfulness or untruthfulness.

How to Present a Witness Effectively in Court(blog)

A practical guide from Nolo that offers tips on preparing and presenting witnesses, focusing on clarity and credibility.

The Psychology of Persuasion in the Courtroom(blog)

Explores psychological principles that influence decision-making in legal settings, relevant to how character is perceived.

What is Witness Credibility? (And How to Prove It)(paper)

A detailed guide from the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General on assessing and presenting witness credibility, offering practical insights.

Legal Writing: Structure, Style, and Advocacy(documentation)

While a book, this widely cited resource (and similar texts) covers the principles of structuring legal arguments and presenting parties persuasively.

The Role of Narrative in Persuasive Legal Advocacy(paper)

This academic paper delves into how constructing a compelling narrative, which includes character development, enhances persuasive legal advocacy.

Cross-Examination: The Art of Questioning(blog)

Focuses on how questioning techniques can reveal or undermine a witness's character and credibility, a key aspect of advocacy.

Character Evidence (Federal Rule of Evidence 404)(wikipedia)

Explains the general rules and exceptions regarding the use of character evidence in legal proceedings, providing essential context.

Persuasive Legal Writing: A Practical Guide(documentation)

While a product page, it links to resources and discussions on persuasive writing techniques crucial for presenting parties and witnesses effectively.